Someone sent me inquiry about this recently and I don't remember who it was or where it came from ... this messageboard, pm, email, or from the social schmocial politically correct 'facebook' which I do not participate much. I must have accidentally deleted that message.

The person I think read the Stop Motion Works Ol' Classic & Infamous Open Hole Ball Joints ....

Open Hole Ball Joints - Drilling Balls - Brazing Balls to Rods

The inquiry question was: What are some of the advantages & disadvantages of 'Open Hole Ball Joints'??

Surely ... many of you savvy, information compulsive hungry kids out here, can analyze the differences or pros & cons between Open Hole Joints and Milled-style Socketed Joints???? Put on your thinking caps and discuss amongst yourselves  ....

Views: 224

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Oh-oh-I know!-I know! Open hole ball joints are 0.023% lighter than milled sockets! What do I win?

How about a Kewpie doll? (Whatever that is!)

Only you're WRONG!!! 

 

You're obviously thinking of Open Hole Pepsi - all the calories, none of the taste. 

Some of the actual advantages would include:

You can make the open hole versions with just a few inexpensive tools like a drill press, hacksaw, hand files or maybe a dremel. They involve much less work and knowledge and are much more forgiving, not requiring the precise 'gnat's ass' tolerances (Hah! do I get extra points for that one?) necessary for the original recipe joints (wait - my analogy is falling apart now - I believe open hole joints were probably in use before ball and socket, or am I wrong there?)

I sent you that message via Facebook.

To all entries, we appreciate your participation but there can be only one winner ... Strider WINS!  As consolation prize, I was going to offer Hostess Twinkies or their Chocolate Cup Cakes (my favorite) but unfortunately, certain Dark Negative Forces 'out there' has shut Hostess down and they are no more, zero, non-existent .

Yes ... one can do Open Hole Joints with minimalistic equipment and be very portable. Rather than relying on much machining equipment ... the Armaturist using hand-tactile old world crafting techniques. To prepare for the upcoming power/energy shortages & brown-outs, you can probably construct stop motion  armatures with almost NO electric power. You know ... out in the woods in a cabin. Get the tools Strider listed and ALSO - an old antique hand powered drill press & bench wheel grinder! 

With regards to the 'Technical' - Open hole ball joints could be weaker than milled socketed joints such as in the ankles & toes where usually high joint tensions might be needed. The hole takes away some of the joint strength compared to having no hole or minimal hole (in milled sockets). Also, open holes might be slightly bulkier or larger .... HOWEVER ... in most cases, and if you are not into Burton'esque Skinny Arse Ankles & Wrists or Emaciated Cadaverous puppet designs ... Open hole ball joints should serve MOST of the Stop Motion needs. The high end Armature engineer elitiists sometimes look down at open hole joints. I could be classified as one of them but I am NOT! I say ... WHATEVER WORKS to CREATE the ANIMATION. The audience do not care how you got there.  

I already understand, some into the TECHNICAL aspects of Armatures. Been there, done that. One can get preoccupied with it which is okay (armatures). Others though, if your goal is to do and create ANIMATION, you also have to focus on other aspects of  a Stop Motion production (not just the armatures) ... but I digress.

Thanks a lot guys . That pretty much answers my question (funny though, because I was starting to think the same stuff a month ago when I started making my alien's armature).

LIOs Nephew said:

To all entries, we appreciate your participation but there can be only one winner ... Strider WINS!  As consolation prize, I was going to offer Hostess Twinkies or their Chocolate Cup Cakes (my favorite) but unfortunately, certain Dark Negative Forces 'out there' has shut Hostess down and they are no more, zero, non-existent .

Yes ... one can do Open Hole Joints with minimalistic equipment and be very portable. Rather than relying on much machining equipment ... the Armaturist using hand-tactile old world crafting techniques. To prepare for the upcoming power/energy shortages & brown-outs, you can probably construct stop motion  armatures with almost NO electric power. You know ... out in the woods in a cabin. Get the tools Strider listed and ALSO - an old antique hand powered drill press & bench wheel grinder! 

With regards to the 'Technical' - Open hole ball joints could be weaker than milled socketed joints such as in the ankles & toes where usually high joint tensions might be needed. The hole takes away some of the joint strength compared to having no hole or minimal hole (in milled sockets). Also, open holes might be slightly bulkier or larger .... HOWEVER ... in most cases, and if you are not into Burton'esque Skinny Arse Ankles & Wrists or Emaciated Cadaverous puppet designs ... Open hole ball joints should serve MOST of the Stop Motion needs. The high end Armature engineer elitiists sometimes look down at open hole joints. I could be classified as one of them but I am NOT! I say ... WHATEVER WORKS to CREATE the ANIMATION. The audience do not care how you got there.  

I already understand, some into the TECHNICAL aspects of Armatures. Been there, done that. One can get preoccupied with it which is okay (armatures). Others though, if your goal is to do and create ANIMATION, you also have to focus on other aspects of  a Stop Motion production (not just the armatures) ... but I digress.

I disqualified myself from this competition. Even though I've milled a number of sockets, I'm not convinced I got additional surface area.  The mill and the ball need to be exactly exact and the same without any non-sameness for there to be full contact. I rely on an inner "open hole" as a backup contact surface.

What I *do* get from milling is a socket that wraps cleanly around the ball and has the extra strength of that metal.  Also I can file away some of the end to allow freedom of movement in those emaciated joints.

Wait what ~ !!?

Hostess has gone under? Seriously??!! Wow, the end of an era truly! 

I only gave a partial answer, leaving it open for others to talk about the disadvantages of the humble open hole ball joint and the advantages of milling and lathing. Dave, thanks for staying out - I could never have matched your high-tech terminology. I don't know tech talk like exactly exact and no non-sameness

Reply to Discussion

RSS

MESSAGE BOARD QUICK LINKS

Message Board

I want to make animal puppets

Started by Robert in CLAY. Last reply by StopmoNick 1 hour ago. 2 Replies

Hi I am making a Noah's ark video and I need to make at least 10 types of puppet animals I am on planning on using clay and wire armature, only trouble is I don't know how to go about it I've looked everywhere for tutorials and diagrams with no luck…Continue

Magic Marker

Started by Jack McCaffrey in YOUR STOPMO FILM PROJECT 7 hours ago. 0 Replies

This is an animation I started production on back in January of this year, and finished it up just last month in July. Attempted to step outside my comfort zone by mixing claymation, 2D animation, and human animation. Focused more on the subtle…Continue

Please Introduce Yourself

Started by Anthony Scott in CHAT BOARD. Last reply by Jack McCaffrey 8 hours ago. 417 Replies

Use this space to tell everyone about yourself and your interest in stop motion animation.Continue

Introduction and recent animation "Marshmallow Martyr"

Started by Rick Jacobs in YOUR STOPMO FILM PROJECT 18 hours ago. 0 Replies

Hello Fellow Stopmo Animators,I am new to this discussion board, but a long-time stopmo animator. I used to do stopmo years ago (with a 35mm Mitchell movie camera), and I would like to get back into it professionally.I'm really looking forward to…Continue

My super smooth stop-motion!

Started by Mikael Ohlson in ANIMATOR TALK. Last reply by Don Carlson yesterday. 5 Replies

Hello! I have just recently finished a new video that is now on YouTube. As always, I aim for animation just as smooth as CG. Tell me what you think of it!…Continue

Puppet Putty SAMPLE run

Started by Don Carlson in CLAY yesterday. 0 Replies

Hi folks, If anyone wants to try a 7oz pack of Puppet Putty, send me a message with your P.O. Box or  mailing address and I'll just have you pay the shipping. Normally it would be the cost of the clay + shipping, but for the first production run, I…Continue

Photos

Loading…

BLOGS

Create a Blog for your personal page. Go to My Page and click on Blog Posts. Access all Blog Posts here.

Members

© 2014   Created by Anthony Scott.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

.xg_widget_forum_index_index .xg_column.xg_span-7.xg_last {display:none;} .xg_widget_forum_topic_listForCategory .xg_column.xg_span-7.xg_last {display:none;} .xg_widget_forum_topic_show .xg_column.xg_span-7.xg_last {display:none;}